Midseason NFL Quarterback Tiers: Reviewing the 2026 Season's Passers
An analysis of the 2026 NFL season's midpoint quarterback tiers highlights struggling starters, reclamation projects, and players at the bottom of the league.
🏈NFLPhoto: Fox Sports
Key points
- Midseason review evaluates 32 expected Week 18 starting quarterbacks.
- Fernando Mendoza steps in for the Raiders following Kirk Cousins' return to Minnesota.
- Replacement-level tier features struggling starters including Deshaun Watson, J.J. McCarthy, and Daniel Jones.
With the 2026 NFL season reaching its midpoint, analysts have revisited preseason quarterback tiers to evaluate performance over the first two months. The evaluation covers 32 expected Week 18 starting signal-callers, excluding players lost for the year like Jaxson Dart and Gardner Minshew, while including Lamar Jackson and Jalen Hurts.
At the bottom tier of replacement-level players, multiple quarterbacks are facing immense pressure. Deshaun Watson has struggled outside of clutch moments, while J.J. McCarthy continues to deal with pocket presence issues in New York. Miami's Malik Willis remains a stopgap, Daniel Jones appears broken, and Carson Beck was pushed into action after starting the year buried on Arizona's depth chart.
Other notable transitions include Fernando Mendoza taking over the Raiders' starting role after Kirk Cousins was sent back to Minnesota. First-overall pick Mendoza is viewed as a quick processor with high upside, though the offense shifts under his command. Meanwhile, veterans like Justin Herbert have battled struggles within new offensive schemes, and Matthew Stafford faces questions regarding his mobility as a 38-year-old.
What to watch next: Monitor how struggling quarterbacks adjust their play styles and whether replacement-level starters can retain their jobs as the second half of the 2026 NFL season unfolds.
Source Fox Sports — foxsports.com/stories/nfl/2026-nfl-quarterback-tiers-midseason ↗
Read next
🎓College SportsFormer Columbia Players Call for Accountability as Coach Megan Griffith Returns
Coach Megan Griffith is set to return to the Columbia women's basketball program following a three-game suspension, despite continued calls from former players for furthe…
🧠AI AnalysisMidseason Defensive Shifts: Uche Named Captain, McDonald Earns Expanded Role
The Dolphins have promoted Joshua Uche to team captain following a player request, while the Jets plan to increase Will McDonald IV's defensive role.
⚾MLBSan Francisco Giants Prioritize Draft Capital Over Qualifying Offer Free Agents
San Francisco Giants President of Baseball Operations Buster Posey confirmed the team will avoid signing free agents attached to qualifying offers to protect their draft …
⚾MLBSan Francisco Giants Appoint James Rowson as Offensive Coordinator
The San Francisco Giants are hiring former Yankees hitting coach James Rowson to oversee their offense, while also naming Taira Uematsu as first base coach.
🏒NHLDan Hicks, Iconic NBC Sports Play-by-Play Voice, Passes Away at 64
Dan Hicks, the veteran NBC Sports play-by-play announcer who defined generations of Olympic swimming and Alpine skiing coverage, has passed away unexpectedly at the age o…
🎓College SportsWake Forest Locks Up Head Coach Jake Dickert With Long-Term Extension
Wake Forest has signed football coach Jake Dickert to a long-term contract extension following an impressive 8-1 start to the season.